How a Single Redditor Sparked the Wall Street Revolution Everyone's Talking About (2024)

Well, folks, the GameStop saga is in the news once again. After a multitude of investigations, documentaries, and referendums, the little Redditors that could just received the Hollywood treatment. This weekend, Dumb Money hits theaters, starring the likes of Paul Dano, Pete Davidson, America Ferrera, Anthony Ramos, Seth Rogen, Shailene Woodley, and much, much more. In the film, Dano plays one of the movement's ringleaders, Keith Gill, who—after throwing a rock at Wall Street—gets himself into a world of sh*t. Antics ensue.

Back in 2021, when the GameStop kerfuffle was the biggest story in the country, John McDermott's deep-dive into its intricacies, absurdity, and vast financial jargon is the only story that left me feeling well-versed in the whole ordeal. Before heading into the theater, I highly recommend you give John's story—which was published on January 27, 2021—another look.—Brady Langmann, Entertainment Editor

News about the stock market rarely crosses over into the cultural mainstream, and historically when that’s happened, it’s meant some catastrophic financial event has taken place. (See: The housing and stock market crashes of 2008.)

But the stock market was the single biggest news story Wednesday, financial or otherwise, due to a group of Reddit sh*tlords pumping up a collection of stocks and pushing some billion-dollar financial institutions to the brink of bankruptcy.

Hedge fund Melvin Capital needed a $2.75 billion bailout on Monday after the stock price for GameStop, the video game retailer, spiked to more than $70 a share over the weekend. Just a month earlier, the stock was hovering near $15. Melvin was shorting the stock, hence the need for a bailout. Reports of Melvin Capital’s financial struggles sent GameStop’s share price soaring even higher, though, to more than $100 a share on Monday, putting the hedge fund in an even more precarious financial decision. As of this writing, the stock was trading for $330 per share—77 times higher than its share price of $4.28 a year ago.

The GameStop stock rally is the handiwork of r/WallStreetBets, a Reddit community where people share news, memes and personal anecdotes about playing the stock market. Here’s how the WallStreetBets group came to power, and how they’re wielding their collective capacity to troll the stock market—and make millions of dollars doing it.

How WallStreetBets became a major market force.

WallStreetBets started as a haven for retail bros, 20- and 30-something amateur traders who try to strike it big making short-term options bets on the stock market. But during the pandemic the group has grown into a legitimate financial force, with the power to manipulate markets and topple institutional investment outfits.

Activity in the group has exploded during the pandemic, presumably because people started day-trading stocks to pass the time while at home. The subreddit grew from 450,000 members in January 2019 to 774,000 members in January 2020, a 72 percent increase, according to Subreddit Stats. WallStreetBets has added nearly 1.3 million new members since then, however, a nearly 200 percent increase year-over-year.

The “Granddaddy” of the GameStop Surge

The plan to pump GameStop actually goes all the way back to September 2019, when WSB member Deepf*ckingValue posted about making call options for GME (GameStop’s ticker symbol) for January 2021. DFV is the “granddaddy” of the GME stock surge, according to Shiv Abrol, an analyst at Roystone Capital who monitors WSB as part of his professional due diligence.

A call option is a contract that gives the owner the right, but not the obligation, to buy a stock at a future date, at a predetermined price. (Options are popular because you’re not left holding the bag if the market goes against you.)

In this case, DFV bought in 2019 the right to buy GameStop stock on January 15, 2021, at $8 a share. If the stock price is below $8 by the expiration date, the options are worthless. If the stock price is above that $8 threshold, however, the options are in the money, meaning they have intrinsic value.

And boy, did those options end up having value. DFV became increasingly convinced of his GME bet as the months wore on, buying even more GME call options at various strike prices and expiration dates throughout 2020 and 2021. He never wavered, even as his options fluctuated wildly in value. Still, he kept buying new GME calls. DFV was going “YOLO,” the WSB term for doubling down, again and again, on a single, potentially life-changing longshot stock bet.

DFV would be rewarded, handsomely, for his faith. By August 2020, his contracts were worth $600,000. In September, he crested $1 million. Mid-October, $2.3 million. He entered 2021 with more than $3.1 million in GME contracts, and then sh*t got really crazy. As DFV’s legend grew, more people on WSB got in on the action, pushing the GME price higher and higher. As of his latest update, DFV’s E-Trade account is worth $22.8 million, $4.4 million of which is in cash he pulled out. And it all started with $53,000 in options premiums.

Squeezing the short-sellers

While this is great for DFV and the other WSB members who have made tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars riding the GME wave, it’s been hell for Melvin Capital.

Melvin had $55 million worth of put options on GameStop, which are the opposite of calls. Puts assume the share price of a stock will go down and give their owners the option to sell a stock at a certain price. Melvin assumed GameStop’s stock would fall, and bought puts allowing Melvin to sell GameStop’s stocks above the market price, netting Melvin a profit. The stock obviously went up, instead, rendering those put options worthless.

Join Esquire Select

The real problem for Melvin is that it was also shorting GameStop, meaning it was borrowing shares of GameStop, selling them on the market and using those proceeds to make other investments. Problem is, Melvin eventually has to return those GameStop shares. So now Melvin has to buy GameStop at their new, inflated price, only to give those shares back to the original owner.

It’s not illegal, per se

On its face, the GameStop surge appears to be a classic pump-and-dump scheme, in which a group of people collude to hype up a stock, artificially increase its share price and then sell at a profit.

There have been talks about the Securities Exchange Commission coming down on WallStreetBets and other online stock forums, but the tricky part is there is no evidence of fraud or insider trading. All of this information is being exchanged in the open, on a public forum. There’s no law against a group of investors taking the same position in a stock, even if they’re doing it as a massive troll.

It’s about more than making money

Sure, the dudes on WSB want to make money. Who doesn’t? But them putting the collective squeeze on Wall Street is about more than making a buck. It’s about wreaking a little havoc on an enormous public stage.

You can see this manifest in the stocks WSB chooses to pump. BlackBerry, BlockBuster and GameStop are all relics of the millennial era, and all of those companies are experiencing WSB-induced surges in stock prices.

It’s easy to dismiss this behavior as trolling, which it is to a large extent. But there’s a philosophical element to it. WSB isn’t trying to harm ordinary people—it’s attempting to stick it to the financial establishment that orchestrated the 2008 financial collapse, and prove that the stock market often has no connection to reality.